5 Best Cornstarch Substitutes for Chicken Pot Pie

Quick tip: Requires longer cooking to remove raw flour taste but yields a thick, creamy filling with a slightly denser texture.

All-purpose flour thickens by absorbing liquid and swelling during cooking, forming a starch gel that stabilizes the filling. It is less potent than cornstarch, so a higher quantity is needed. The gluten in flour also adds body to the filling, which can be beneficial for the hearty nature of chicken pot pie.

To avoid a pasty or floury taste, it’s important to cook the flour thoroughly in the fat (butter or oil) before adding liquids, essentially making a roux. This step ensures the flour’s starch granules are fully gelatinized and the raw flavor is eliminated.

Compared to cornstarch, flour produces a slightly more opaque and less glossy filling with a thicker, more substantial mouthfeel. This can enhance the rustic appeal of the dish but may lack the silkiness cornstarch imparts.

Quick tip: Creates a slightly grainier texture but maintains good thickening and is gluten-free.

Rice flour thickens by gelatinizing starch granules when heated with liquid, similar to cornstarch but with a coarser granule size. This makes it suitable for thickening the chicken pot pie filling without adding gluten.

To optimize texture, it’s best to mix rice flour with cold liquid before heating to prevent clumping. Cooking time should be sufficient to fully hydrate the starch and avoid a raw taste.

The final filling will be less glossy and may have a mild graininess compared to cornstarch, but it remains stable during baking and provides a satisfactory creamy consistency.

Quick tip: Adds a slight nutty flavor and a gel-like consistency, but can alter the filling’s texture and color.

Ground flaxseed forms a mucilaginous gel when mixed with water, which can act as a thickening agent. This gel mimics some of the viscosity cornstarch provides, helping to bind the filling ingredients.

Because flaxseed gel is less neutral than starches, it’s important to balance the flavor profile of the filling. It also thickens differently, so the filling may be less smooth and slightly denser.

The final dish will have a more rustic texture and a subtle nutty undertone, which can complement the savory components but diverges from the classic silky pot pie filling.

Quick tip: Has a distinct flavor and produces a thicker, slightly grainy texture; best for those who enjoy legume notes.

Chickpea flour thickens by absorbing liquid and swelling starch granules, similar to all-purpose flour but with a stronger flavor profile. It adds protein and fiber, contributing to a hearty filling.

To prevent a raw or bitter taste, chickpea flour should be cooked thoroughly in fat before adding liquids, similar to making a roux. This also helps smooth the texture.

The resulting filling is thicker and less glossy than with cornstarch, with a noticeable earthy flavor that may complement the savory chicken and vegetables but changes the traditional flavor balance.

Quick tip: Glucomannan thickens effectively with less quantity but can cause a gummy texture if overused or not properly dissolved.

Glucomannan is a soluble fiber derived from konjac root that forms a highly viscous gel when hydrated. Its strong thickening ability means only a small amount is needed to replace cornstarch.

It thickens quickly at room temperature and remains stable during baking, but excessive amounts can cause a gummy or jelly-like texture. It is best to dissolve it thoroughly in cold liquid before heating.

Compared to cornstarch, glucomannan produces a more elastic and less glossy filling, which may feel unusual in a traditional chicken pot pie but can be useful for low-carb or keto adaptations.